The 23rd annual the Vidéoformes International Festival of Video Art and New Media was launched on Wednesday the 12th of March in the presence of elected officials, Clermont-Ferrand’s Mayor Serge Godard, along with several local and foreign artists, and well-wishing members of the faithful and passionate public. Following the presentation of the various installations that form the “public architecture” of this very beautiful edition of the festival, around 100 of us came together at the main center of the exhibition for a buffet dinner that gave a warm ambiance without any sense of excess. I left the exhibition around 11:30 PM, delighted with this first day and with the quality of the contact that I had been able sense among all of the participants.
At the end of the evening, a small group of artists (German, American, Italian) got together, accompanied by the director of Vidéoformes at the “Bar du commerce” on the place Gaillard, to end things with a “last glass”. When the bar was closing, and all was calm and serene, a group of police raided the bar, ejecting all of the artists. Our friend Triny Prada, artist-in-residence for this year’s festival showing her work concerning Genetically Modified Foods, was at that very moment taking photos of her friends. The police immediately confiscated her camera, arguing that she was not authorised to take photos of police officers and saying that the camera was pointed towards the police. The officer then detained Triny without heistation and put her in a police car. Despite the protests of the Vidéformes Festival’s Director ,Triny was put in a cell at the central police station for “public drunkenness”. Triny asked if a bankette at a bar was public, and if a customer at a bar was causing trouble in public. She was taken to her cell. Triny asked how long she would have to stay there, and the officer responded “Less time than Ingrid Betancourt” (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ingrid_Betancourt). Considering that Triny was in Bogota just a few weeks ago supporting relatives of the hostages taken by the Colombian rebel group FARC, she not share the officers sense of humour. After that, Triny was left to spend the night in a sordid cell whose temperature was not over 5°C/40°F with only a thin blouse to keep her warm. It is shameful that a woman be treated this way in a Democracy in which it’s president has said that he waits anxiously to hear of the release of one of his compatriots from the Venezuelan frontier.
The morning after this horrible incident, which has tarnished the image of our Festival, the of Clermont-Ferrand, the region of Auvernge and the image of France; I quickly contacted the Police Prefecture. To their credit, they were attentive and coruteous (possibly too attentive when their first question was “Is she an illegal immigrant?”). Triny was finally released at 9:30 this morning. Her camera was destroyed and her memory card was lost. When asked “Where is the memory card?”, the police clerk said ‘It never existed.’ and that Triny voluntarily threw her camera to the ground.
A complaint will be filed with the French Prosecuter’s Office.
Outrageous! Yesterday I saw policemen in California, dressed in jackboots, black uniforms and brandishing weapons towards college students and yelling “Don’t call me a fascist! I’m just trying to do my job!”. Apparently his job was to arrest a protester in a tree or anyone who came too close to the tree. They were unable to arrest the protester and so they cordoned off the tree and read it it’s rights.
The only word for this is UNACCEPTABLE. I came to France to get away from things like this.
My deepest sympathies go out to Triny and I hope that the complaint with the French Prosecutor’s Office can lead to something.
However, I must say that I have big doubts about it because since the memory card was “gone”, there could be no evidence as to whether Triny did point the camera at the police or not.
I suppose that there were quite a few eyewitnesses to this case, and I hope for the very best outcome.
Again, my sympathies go to Triny who had to experience that night in the cell at that low temperature. Police officers stepping over their line is unfortunately happening all over the world, and we as a public should make our mark in protesting against it.
triny!
this is insane
i’m glad you are ok
but this is a shame
we are with you!
“Je leur parle avec des mots poétiques. Ils font un effort pour ne pas me rouer de coups. Je les regarde avec des yeux empreints de bonté. Ils me rendent des regards de lame.Je leur souris avec sympathie et confiance. Ils crispent leurs bouches minces. Alors je m’en vais – et ils me fusillent dans le dos.” (Louis Calaferte)
The actions of these police are just completely unconscionable. We have got to stop accepting this kind of unreasonable behavior.
Parfaitement lamentable ! La moindre des choses serait des excuses et une réparation pour le matériel détruit.
The whole story is very stupid and unfortunately i also think it can happen in more countries.
But i sure wish you all manage to go to the bottom of it and make those policeman feel bad about it and off course pay for their actions.
we really shouldn’t accept it.
How have other tyrannical laws been changed?
Photographing police officers is the only way ‘just folks’ can document abuses and kindnesses. These kinds of laws restricting documentation of anyone must be abolished for sure.
So sorry this had to color your event, Loiez. So sorry your friend was traumatized in this way.
Appalling implementation of extremely insidious laws. Viva Triny. Viva freedom of expression. Viva Art.